Refuting Zakir Naik on High Level of Knowledge of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) in the field of Hadith Science
Refuting Zakir Naik on High Level of
Knowledge of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) in the field of Hadith Science
Youtube [English: 47 mins 37 secs]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hSF4uUX-4gs
Youtube [Urdu: 57 mins 17 secs]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dZC0JjWSQ6s
★ About Video:
In this Video, Zakir Naik in order to
disregard the High Level of Knowledge of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) and other Imam
of Fiqh in the field of Hadith Science tried to spread this rumour and
confusion to his Audience:
1: “We have to realise that during the time
of Imam Abu Hanifa, Imam Shaafi.. May Allah have mercy upon them all.. All the
Hadith’s were not compiled”
2: “Imam Anu Hanifa May Allah have mercy upon
him Rahimahullah.. He was a great scholar.. we love him.. we respect him BUT
not that he made mistake purposefully.. may be these Hadith’s which I quoted of
Sahih Bukhari Volume: 1 Hadith No: 781 to 782 and the Hadith of Sahih Muslim
Volume No: 1 Hadith No: 811 to 816.. this may not have reached him”
3: With respect to the Compilation of the
Hadith’s, He said: “And during the time of these Great Aiima’s: Imam Abu
Hanifa, Imam Malik, Imam Shaafi, Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal ..May Allah have mercy
on all of them… it was yet continuing.. it was not yet completed.. Later on
Imam Bukhari came then Imam Muslim came.. Imam Abu Dawood.. Imam Tirmidhi and
then later on after their demise of these great four Aiima’s the process was
more formulated.. so therefore based on whatever was the knowledge they had..
they gave the opinion”
That’s how Zakir Naik is fooling his
Audience.
All the Four Imams of the Fiqhi Madhhabs
[Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a), Imam Malik (r.a), Imam Shaafi (r.a) & Imam Ahmad
ibn Hanbal (r.a)] were very well aware of All the Hadith’s of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ as they were not just the Imam’s of Fiqh but they were Great Grand
Imam’s of the Hadith too. Before compiling their respective Fiqhi Madhhabs, by
travelling to so many places they first collected the Hadith’s of the Prophet
Muhammad ﷺ even before compilation of the Classical
Famous Hadith books by the Imam of Hadith’s like Imam Bukhari (rah), Imam
Muslim (rah) etc.
More than 500 books of Hadith were compiled
even before the compilation of the Sahih Bukhari, like for example:
1: Muwatta of Imam Malik (r.a)
2: Musnad of Imam Shaafi (r.a)
3: Musnad Ahmed bin Hanbal of Imam Hanbal
(r.a) where he collected 40,000 Hadith’s
4: Musannaf ibn Abi Shaybah
5: Musannaf Abdur Razzaak
6: Musnad Daarmi
7: Hadith book of Imam Zuhri (rah)
8: Hadith Book of Imam Abdullah bin Mubarak
(rah)
9: Hadith Book of Sufyaan As Sauri (rah)
Etc
These four Imams of the Fiqhi Madhhabs took
the Hadith’s directly from the Compilers of those Hadith Books (A Heart to
Heart Transmission of Hadith). Thus they were having the Short Chains of
Narrations (Sanad) going back to the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ .
Whereas Imam Bukhari and other Imams of the
Hadith collected those Hadith through long Chains of Narrations because they
came much after their time.
Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) narrated 16 Hadith’s
directly from the Sahaba Karaam (r.a) which none of the Imam of Hadith’s did.
Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) was a Taabi whereas
none of the Imams of the Hadith was a Taabi.
Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) narrated more than 3000
Hadith’s directly from the Various Taabi Karaam (r.a) having just Two people
(Sahabi & Taabi) between Him and Prophet Muhammad ﷺ in the Sanad (Chain of Narration of the Hadith) whereas the Same
Hadith’s reached to Imam Bukhari (rah) & Other Imams of Hadith’s through
Long Chains of Narrations.
The Teachers of Imam Bukhari (rah) &
other Imam’s of Hadith from whom they
took & study the Hadith’s were the Students of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a).
Then after becoming the Specialist in The
Hadith Science & in all other Islamic Sciences (like Qur’anic Science,
Tafsir, Arabic Grammar, Logic etc), the Imam’s of the Four Fiqhi Madhhabs
Encoded the Islamic Law which became famous by their names: Hanfi Fiqh, Shaafi
Fiqh, Maliki Fiqh and Hanbli Fiqh respectively.
Four different Madhhabs of Fiqh (Hanfi,
Shaafi, Maaliki and Hanbli) are four different interpretations of Qur’an and
Hadith in the field of Fiqh (Islamic Jurisprudence) because of the difference
in the Usul (Principles) of these Four Imams and their Madhhabs.
These Four Imams have different Usul
(Principles) in Tafsir, in Hadith, in Fiqh, in Arabic Grammer etc.
So when they applied these Usul’s
(Principles) on Qur’an and Hadith in order to solve a particular Fiqhi issue,
they sometimes reached to the different Results. That’s how these Four Fiqhi
Madhhabs came into existence.
Thus these Four different Madhhabs of Fiqh
(Hanfi, Shaafi, Maaliki and Hanbli) are simply Four Different Interpretations
of Islam.
The Number of Visits of Imam Bukhari (rah) to
a Place indicates the amount of knowledge he received in Hadith science from
that place.
Imam Bukhari (rah) Visited Syria (Mulk e
Shaam), Egypt, Al Jazirah (Now a Territory which comes in between Syria, Iraq
& Turkey) for Two times.
Imam Bukhari (rah) visited Basra for Four
times. Basra is the land of Imam Hasan Basri (r.a) who is the Fountain of
Tasawwuf (Sufism).
Imam Bukhari (rah) stayed in Hijaaz (That is
in Mecca Sharif & Madinah Sharif) for Six Years.
And Imam Bukhari (rah) visited Baghdad and
Kufa COUNTLESS TIMES.
What is this place Kufa and Baghdad?
Kufa is the place of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a)
where he was born & lived whereas Baghdad is the place where Imam Abu
Hanifa (r.a) died.
Kufa had become the Army Centre, Military
Centre of the Sahaba Karaam in the time of Hazrat Umar Al Faruq (r.a). And then
it had become the Capital of Islam (Dar ul Khilafah) in the time of Hazrat Ali
(r.a). Over 1500 Sahaba Karaam shifted from Haramain Shariff to Kufa, they
lived in Kufa and this is the maximum number of Sababa Karaam who ever lived in
a City in the Whole World.
Imam Ibn Siriin (r.a) who was a great Taabi
stated that when he visited Kufa, he saw 4000 Taba’iin sitting there and
delivering the knowledge of Hadith to the people.
So, Virtually the KUFA had become the BIGGEST
CENTER OF THE HADITH OF PROPHET MUHAMMAD ﷺ.
This was the place where Imam Abu Hanifa
(r.a) was born, where he received the Knowledge of Hadith and where he Compiled
in the light of these Hadith – “Al Fiqh ul Hanafi”.
So, this is how Imam Bukhari (rah) Compiled
Sahih Bukhari by visiting those cities few times and By Visiting the land of
Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) that is Kufa & Baghdad countless times.
Imam Bukhari (rah) received Knowledge and
Hadith from atleast 40 Students of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a). This proves that Imam
Bukhari (rah) is the Grand Student of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a).
The Father [Imam Ismail bin Ibrahim bin
Mughira Al Bukhari (rah)] of Imam Bukhari (rah) passed away when Imam Bukhari
(rah) was very young so Imam Bukhari (rah) couldn’t receive Knowledge &
Hadith directly from his father. But he received the Knowledge & Hadith
from his father through Wijadah (that is by Himself studying from the left
collections of Books of His father).
There were Three Prominent Teachers of the
Father of Imam Bukhari (rah) [according to Al Tarikh ul Kabir of Imam Bukhari
(rah) & Other Imams also mentioned the same]:
1: Imam Abdullah bin Mubarak (r.a)
2: Imam Hammad bin Zayd (r.a)
3: Imam Malik bin Anas (r.a)
The First Two Teachers are the Eminent and
Prominent Students of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a).
(Jameh Bayaan ul Ilm on Page: 289)
Imam Abu Umar Ibn Abdul Bar Al Andulusi (rah)
who was the Greatest Scholar in Asmaa wa Rijaal says (in his Book Al Intiqa on
Page: 201) that Imam Hammad bin Zayd (r.a) Received Large Number of Hadith’s
from Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) and transmitted those Hadith’s through Imam Abu
Hanifa (r.a).
And Imam Abdullah bin Mubarak (r.a) was the staunch
follower of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) and use to give Fatwa according to the
Madhhab of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a).
That’s how Imam Bukhari (rah) received the
Knowledge of Hadith and became the Grand Student of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a)
through his Father’s side besides many other sides.
The Pride of Imam Bukhari is in his
Transmission of 22 Sulasiyaat Hadith [Three Persons in between Prophet Muhammad
ﷺ
and Him] in His Sahih Bukhari which none of the other Imam’s of Sihah Sittah
were able to transmit even One such short chain Narration. And He received the
20 Sulasiyaat Hadith’s out of 22 from the Students of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a).
He received:
1: Eleven (11) Sulasiyaat Hadith’s from Imam
Makki bin Ibrahim (rah) [Direct Student of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a)]
2: Six (6) Sulasiyaat Hadith’s from Imam Abu
Aasim An Nabeel Ad Dahaaq (rah) [Direct Student of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a)]
3: Three (3) from Imam Muhammad bin Abdullah
Al Ansaari (rah) [Direct Student of Imam Muhammad (r.a) & Imam Abu Yusuf
(r.a) who were the Direct Main Students of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a)]
That’s how even the pride of Imam Bukhari
(rah) in the field of narrating Hadith’s is because of Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a)!
Whereas,
1: The Number of the Hadith’s which Imam Abu
Hanifa (r.a) narrated with just One Sahabi in between Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and Him are 16
2: The Number of the Sunayiyaat Hadith’s
which Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) narrated with just Two Persons in between Prophet
Muhammad ﷺ
and Him are around 2000.
3: The Number of the Sulasiyaat Hadith’s
which Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a) narrated with just Three Persons in between Prophet
Muhammad ﷺand Him are 4000
[whereas the Sulasiyaat of Imam Bukhari (rah) are just 22. Can you spot the
difference in the level of Knowledge of Hadith between Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a)
and Imam Bukhari (rah)]
All this proves that Imam Abu Hanifa (r.a)
was not just the Imam of Fiqh but He was Great Grand Imam of Hadith of Our
Beloved Prophet Muhammad ﷺ
Kindly watch the complete video in order to
understand properly.
FOR MORE INFO, KINDLY VISIT
AND STUDY MY THIS COMPILATION:
http://mrehan786.blogspot.in/2015/11/AbuHanifaImameHadith.html
